Progressive to Pay $15.2M Settlement Over Underpaid Total Loss Claims in Colorado


Progressive to Pay $15.2M Settlement Over Underpaid Total Loss Claims in Colorado

 

Progressive Direct and Progressive Preferred Insurance have agreed to pay about $15.2 million to settle a class action lawsuit alleging the company shortchanged Colorado drivers whose vehicles were declared total losses. The case centers on claims that were paid out using a valuation method the lawsuit says improperly lowered what policyholders were owed. Our consumer reporter has long warned readers to double check insurance payouts before accepting them, and this settlement shows why that caution matters, especially when an insurer handles the math behind a total loss claim.

According to the class action, Progressive based payments to insureds on Mitchell valuation reports that applied what is called a projected sold adjustment. Plaintiffs allege this adjustment is improper and that using it to calculate payouts meant drivers received less than the actual cash value of their totaled cars. The lawsuit claims this practice breached Progressive's own policies and its duty of good faith and fair dealing toward policyholders. Progressive has not admitted any wrongdoing in agreeing to the settlement.

How to spot it

  • Your claim was for a vehicle Progressive declared a total loss.
  • The payout was calculated using a Mitchell valuation report.
  • That valuation report applied a projected sold adjustment to reduce the payment.
  • You held a policy with Progressive Direct or Progressive Preferred Insurance in Colorado.

What to do if it happened to you

Under the terms of the settlement, eligible class members can receive a cash payment equal to 68% of their projected sold adjustment impact amount. If you believe your total loss claim with Progressive in Colorado was calculated using this method, you should review the settlement terms to see whether your claim qualifies and follow the process for submitting it to receive your share of the payout.

As always, our consumer reporter urges policyholders not to take an insurer's first offer at face value, particularly on total loss claims where valuation methods can quietly reduce what you are owed. Settlements like this one are a reminder to keep paperwork, ask how a payout figure was reached, and watch for notices about class actions that may apply to a claim you already settled.

Source: Top Class Actions